I’m writing this post to document a situation that I encountered
at this year’s 6th Annual Egg Pageant in Sumner, Georgia. Oh, you
haven’t heard of this pageant? That may be because it isn’t real life. I mean,
it IS real life… but only for the young girls participating. To the rest of us-
this pageant doesn’t exist and the decisions made by the pageant judges will
never affect any of our lives directly. This pageant is a tiny, tiny occurrence in the
lives of 200 people MAX. I just so happened to be taking a vacation from
college to visit my family close to Sumner the weekend of the town's Egg Pageant. I decided
to attend the event with my little sister to watch and cheer on a good friend
who was competing that evening (shout out to Jessica Louise Black *wink wink* What's up?!). I have
participated in many pageants in my lifetime and I have attended several
others. In the South, beauty pageants are extremely popular among all ages. I
realized only after moving away to college that many people my age have never witnessed a beauty pageant. So for those people who have no idea what I’m even
talking about- lemme break it down for ya.
Beauty
pageants exist in communities all over this fine country as a creative outlet
and as a means for a bit of friendly competition among young girls. These competitions are very often
low-key community-centered events and simply for funsies (for
instance- this pageant exists to honor local egg farmers). However, as some of
you may have seen on TLC- beauty pageants can get quite extravagant! But I’m
not talking about an extravagant pageant. I’m talking about little bitty baby
competition that means nothing to ANYONE except the girls up on that stage. In
fact, I should have never even thought of this dang pageant again!
Unfortunately, I haven’t been able to forget this junk. Ugh, it’s aggravating. I
want to move on with my life. But I can’t.
The
contestants were divided into maybe 5 small groups. They were divided
appropriately by age. It was actually cute because the oldest age group consisted of 2
adult moms! But anyways, the girls ranged from probably 8 to 19 (these are
estimates because I forget details later due to rage). Our friend Jessica is a senior at Worth County High School and she was so
pretty and amazing and I love her and her parents are so sweet and nice. Ok,
but the situation of the night surrounded the age group right below hers. This
age group was made up of middle school students. Remember how awful middle school
was? Yeah, everyone hates middle school. No one knows who they are in middle
school. Everyone is at their ugliest and most uncomfortable. All of our bodies
got weird in middle school. Everyone is miserable. Middle school is Hell on
Earth. I’m sorry, was that just me? Anyways, all of these girls were in middle
school. Nonetheless, they were all BEAUTIFUL up on that sparkly stage! There were 4 girls in this age group. Remember- this pageant is TINY.
Four middle school girls were competing for the same ‘Queen’ title this
evening. Well actually, they were all there fighting for several titles:
1-
Queen
2-
1st runner up
3-
Best Smile
4-
Best Hair
5-
Most Photogenic
6-
People’s Choice (audience members would vote
with $ for their favorite girl)
7-
Best Hair
8-
Best Dress
9-
Most Beautiful
So, wow, the odds look pretty good! Nine titles for 4 girls!
In fact, I can’t remember (rage) if there was a 2nd Runner-Up… so
there may have been one more possible title! Great odds! This will be great!
Well, I say “great”… but is it kinda strange that we would sign our 13-15 year
old girls up to have their physical appearance judged against their peers’ in
front of their town? Is that strange? Let’s rate these 4 children on how
“beautiful” they are and then announce who wins (and therefore who loses) to
everyone they know. Congratulations to the “Most Beautiful” child. I would
absolutely LOVE to be judged at the “Most Beautiful!” Omg, I would be so proud
of my face! I would literally wear it around everywhere for forever. Yeah, but
cool, anyway. These children are up there. Let’s cut to the chase-
There were 3 tiny pageant girls on display up there in the bright lights… and then there
was one girl who was a little more averagely-sized than the other three. It was
noticeable that she was slightly huskier than the others… but all four
children were gloriously made-up, sparkling and smiling so beautifully for the
judges. The TWO judges that were judging them. Two. Two middle-aged women.
Actually, I don’t know how old they were because #rage, but I DO know that
neither of them had a perfect hourglass shape. There were two, average,
grown-ass women RANKING these children based on their physical appearance.
Soon, their decisions would be read to the auditorium. (Just a side-rant: A
pageant is supposed to have odd-numbered judges.) So, there are the children up
on the stage. Cori-Beth Sutton is the host of the show (omg, she did
spectacularly. She is a freakin’ natural!! You go, girl!!) and as she prepares
to read off the winners, the girlies are smiling and posing to imitate
life-sized Barbies, as one must in this sort of arena. One-by-one the awards
are attached to a winner. After each award is announced, the pageant director
hands the winner the title’s corresponding trophy. Slowly… the huskier child’s
facial expression begins to morph from hopeful to shameful as the number of
remaining available awards runs out. As all three of the other contestants
fumble around trying to hold their new trophies and sashes… the odd-girl-out
begins to realize that she is about to walk away with nothing. I sat in the
audience with my eyes fixed on this child’s facial expression. I thought that
surely she would win SOMETHING. But as time passed… it was clear. The ‘Queen’
was announced last. I watched the losing girl’s face twist into the most
heartbreaking expression I can remember seeing in my entire life. Her hands
ever so slowly shifted from confidently hanging by her sides… to nervously
fiddling with the front of her dress. Her eyes struggled to withhold her tears.
Her face had turned perfectly red by the time Cori-Beth congratulated the
winners and dismissed them from the stage. That sweet child… bless her heart.
As I looked around the auditorium it was clear that everyone noticed what had
just made me shaking mad. SHAKING. I was so furious. She had been the only child to lose. She did not win a single award, but instead had lost in all categories. That girl would remember
this public humiliation for the rest of her life. PUBLIC HUMILIATION. Bright
lights and an auditorium full of family, friends, and schoolmates… For nothing
but humiliation. I was enraged. Her expression broke my heart. And those two
ladies were 100% at fault for her pain. Why would those ladies break that
child’s heart in that way? I never saw the kid again… I looked for her as the
other three kids came out into the audience carrying their trophies… but she
wasn’t there. Her parents got her out of that building immediately.
Knowing how it
feels to be in middle school, I can imagine each of those four girls being so
incredibly nervous throughout the whole day as competition time approached. All
day each child felt nervous that they may trip or be judged unfavorably. And as
the night of the competition drew nearer, these feelings would become almost
impossible to avoid. Being on stage is terrifying for the majority of us.
Imagine this happening to you. Imagine being the loser. The only loser. MY
HEART BROKE. And ask, my sister- I was shaking. As soon as the competition
ended- I headed to the judge’s table.
I approached the
judges shaking and obviously holding back tears. These two ladies, by
definition, score each contestant on numerous scales based on their various
beauty/pageant skills. I asked the first judge to noticed me if there was a
“head judge in charge.” She said there was not. I asked for an email address
that I could reach one of them by. She refused. She told me to say whatever I
needed to say to them right there. I was so angry and disturbed that I couldn’t
speak clearly. I told them that what they did was awful. I didn’t even need to
explain which girl I was talking about when I accused them of being awful. I asked
them HOW they could do that. One of the ladies said, “We don’t have any control
over that. We just tally up the scores.” -a ridiculous thing to say. I replied,
“You’re the ONLY people that have control over this! You are responsible for
this!” I reminded them of how small of an event they were running. I reminded
them that this event doesn’t matter… but that that little girl was going to be
SCARRED by their decision to act carelessly. It was then that they referred me
to the ‘Pageant Director’. WHAT?! The who?! Does she JUDGE these children!? No.
But they called her over to the table to speak with me. Cool, hi. She asked me what my problem was. I told her. She asked me which
girl I was referring to. I said, “ARE YOU KIDDING?! The girl who just got
humiliated by these two in front of all these people! You know who I’m talking
about.” It was at that point that all three ladies involved realized that I
didn’t actually know the child personally. Oops, I guess I’m not a mad parent/sibling.
I might just be an upset member of the human race. She ended the
conversation by saying, “Oh, the little girl who didn’t win anything? Yeah,
we’re taking care of her.” I replied with- “I’M SORRY, YOU’RE WHAT?!?! No,
ma’am.” And I walked off. It took
everything in me not to burst out in tears.
I’m sorry, maybe
the little girl wasn’t as humiliated as it looked. Maybe I am the only one who
wouldn’t be able to go to school the next day. I’m just saying, that was awful
of those two ladies to do to her. They saw what they did. They saw how the
child reacted. And I hope with everything in me that those two thought of that
little girl shying away with defeat and embarrassment as they tried to sleep
that night. I hope that child is stronger than me… because I wouldn’t be able
to come back from that very easily.
I wanted to
get back at the three compassion-less women in this story by trying to get the
story into the Sylvester Local… but I digress. Karma is real when it comes to
disregarding the feelings of others. They’ll get what they bring on. I’m not in
charge of dishing out karma. However- I can document whatever I want for my
personal memories and share it with my family! ;-P
Considering you obviously know nothing about pageants, you should have researched it more before posting your accusations. Those of us who CHOOSE to put our children in pageants are very aware that our children are going to be "judged". Let’s not forget it is a competition. You should be prepared, just as if you were playing football, baseball or any other sport. I have been involved with my daughters in pageants for 10+ years on a local, state and national level and have never come across anyone with the likes of you.
ReplyDeleteIf you are going to quote your statements and mine (yeah I'm one of those compassionless women) you might want to quote it correctly. I was concerned with the girl you are talking about not receiving an award. I do not believe in leaving "1" girl out of a group at any pageant, but it happens, directors are only human. That is what I was referring to with "I have no control over that". When you approached, the other judge and myself had already discussed that very issue. Do I believe this girl should have won the pageant, no but I do believe she should have received a participation trophy.
I was asked to judge the pageant and that is exactly what I did. Girls are judged on facial beauty, poise, personality, smile, hair, dress and overall appearance. We all believe our children are the “most beautiful”. Even though it is a beauty pageant there are a lot more that go into these pageants than a pretty face. If you are so experienced with pageants like you say you are, you would already know this (but that is another story). As far as the email address, please tell me why I would give some girl (who I have never met before) my personal email address? Regarding the director, he/she is always involved when there is someone questioning the results. As far as the girl being humiliated, she didn’t seem too sad when the director spoke with her. She actually won a people’s choice award. She also didn’t seem too sad when MY daughter was offering to help her prepare for her next pageant. This is what we normal people do with girls who are new to this hobby. Guess we are not the compassionless people you thought we were.
Now as a pageant mom, let me explain a few things to you. I have 3 daughters, 2 of which compete in these pageants. This is our hobby and we enjoy it. There have been MANY times my children have walked off stage with NOTHING. There have been MANY times when they have walked off stage with EVERYTHING. So I can understand where you would be confused. However, with all my years of experience I have learned you don’t just put on a dress and curl your hair to win a pageant. Trust me…been there done that. Some of these girls (mine included) have trained for years to win pageants. This training includes: professional pageant coaching, hair and make-up artists, custom outfits and dresses. If these types of pageants don’t agree with someone, then I suggest they enter a natural pageant, where it is judged on facial beauty only.
As far as ridiculous things to say, this blog of yours takes the Supreme title. Instead of reliving your middle school years through a girl you don’t even know, try finding something more productive to do with your time.
You know good and well this Sumner pageant was not a big whoo doo and I also blame you for not using good judgment when judging 4 little girls in a little small town pageant that sounds like you have no business judging. Hello!!!! This is not the big leagues!!!!! We don't need people like you making our children feel insecure. Frankly we don't give a shit about your experience in the pageant world! But I can tell you this you need to work on your heartless uncaring attitude. I bet your child had never ever been in a pageant with 3 other girls and not receive 1 damn award out of 9 categories because the other 3 won every damn one between the 3!!!!!! You and your little buddy judge should be ashamed! From what I understand the little girl and parents left immediately so as far as her planning get next one is prolly a lie!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteIt doesn't matter if its a big whoo doo or not. The fact is every pageant has judges. Judges are to score each child on a scale whether it be 1-10, 1-20 or whatever. Each judge does not know what the other judge has scored and each child is scored individually. There is only a queen, and runner ups which are considered titles. The other titles you are referring to are called optionals and not every contestant enters those "optionals". And yes we have been in pageants with 3 other girls, 1 other girl, and 30 other girls in our group and win nothing and then turn around and compete next weekend and win everything. I do feel bad for the young girl who did not get anything, I also felt bad for the other girls in the pageant who didn't get anything. Because someone did not win does not make me or any other pageant judge a heartless uncaring person.
ReplyDeleteSure it does! You had complete control of that situation and she entered optionals. So I don't care to hear your excuses. And for there to be NO participation trophy is absurd!!!!!! Which I know is not your fault but dang come on that child basically got NOTHING!!!!!!! But empty pockets. Say what you want make excuses throw your expertise around all you want. That pageant SUCKED and in my opinion you suck and a little girl was crushed and That's a fact jack!!!!!
DeleteWell I probably suck to everyone else that didn't win that day too... I have had judges that suck in my opinion also. I hate the girl was heartbroken, but I have been assured by the director she awarded her a title, so that's all I can do.
DeleteUntil that judge stands on stage and gets told the three girls up there with her have better hair, smile, eyes, personality, and are more beautiful then her, her opinion doesn't matter. Yeah, it was a competition, but she did not go into it thinking that would be the outcome. She did it to get dressed up and feel beautiful. I am pretty sure she had a great deal of confidence on that stage before it happen. Nothing hurts worse than not feel pretty enough. If you lost at one sport, try the next. You cant get a new face, body, or self confidence.
ReplyDeleteAnd yeah, pageants were my hobby too. So yes, I understand what it is like. I have also been on many LOSING sport teams. I know what that is like. I can PROMISE you , it is a different feeling
I completely understand what all of you are saying. As a judge I can't control that one girl gets left out. That happens sometimes at pageants. I don't think it's fair to accuse me of being compassionless, heartless and uncaring, because someone did receive an award on stage. I know the director and honestly believe she is a Christian and fair woman. If she had realized one girl was going to be left standing, it would have been corrected before anyone knew what had happened. With this particular sitation, me nor the other judge knew that this girl wasn't going to receive anything. And I do know it is a different feeling as I have left carrying my children out of pageant crying because of similiar situations.
ReplyDeleteThis post has done exactly what I meant for it to do- it has created a conversation. So, now that we have this lovely dialogue, let's discuss some of the ways that we can reform our pageant judging traditions. Boosting the confidence of our youth should be a priority.
ReplyDeleteI agree...Pageants have boosted my daughters' confidence to the extreme. But it did not happen overnight. It took several wins and losses to get that point. My youngest was a very shy girl who would not speak to anyone other than me. Through these pageants, she has experienced both positive and negative feedback. Now she can talk to anyone with confidence and she can also take critisim like a little lady.
ReplyDeleteWith that, maybe having smaller pageants with Sunday dress or just causal clothes would benefit a smaller community.
Ms. Warner,
DeleteI appreciate your soothing response. You seem to have a very calming and loving soul.
I was asked to judge this pageant and everyone had an opportunity to talk with us afterward. During that time, contestants and parents are given the opportunity for feedback. I have never been rude or uncaring to a contestant. I have always provided positive feedback and offered suggestions to the girls when I am judging. However, I am human and will not sit by and let someone who does not know me call me compassion-less, heartless, uncaring and most importantly middle-aged. (Sorry couldn't resist that last one).
I have come to the conclusion that this blogger is a very passionate young lady with a huge heart.
I am wrapping up my blogging experience on this one. I hate that it has escalated this far. Seems like there is alot of confusion and misinformation. I have been assured the girl in which all this is about is well, and was happy with what the director provided her. That is all that matters.
Dear Pageant Judge,
ReplyDeleteYou have a responsibility! Not just the responsibility of judging those who have chosen the Pageant path. Yours is a greater responsibility, because you, my dear, are in a position of leadership!!!!!
This is what I hold you accountable for - This is what our young people deserve:
The greater responsibility for all of us who are women in a leadership role - where we impact the lives of young people, is to lift up those young people - Especially when we are met with a differing opinion. Let me repeat - ESPECIALLY when we are met with a differing opinion. That is where you have the greatest opportunity to lead others!!!!
I get it - the rules of the pageant world are set in stone.
I get it - this young blogger may not understand your "world".
I get it - you may have indeed judged the pageant as it should have been judged. And I would never presume to lay fault or blame on you personally for a situation I have no direct knowledge for.
But - here is where your response is completely off-base:
You are charged with the responsibility of protecting the spirit of all young people!!!! Not just those in your pageant. That is the responsibility you accepted, when you took on the role of "leader".
Yes, there may be specifics of this situation that this young blogger may not understand... but did you demonstrate your leadership responsibilities in your response to her? No, you did not! You immediately became defensive. Did you enlighten and uplift, in your response to her? No, you did not!
And not only that! You had an even greater opportunity, because you ARE in a leadership role in the pageant world, to truly REPRESENT the virtues of the Pageant world. Sadly - your mean-spirited response did nothing to demonstrate the power of pageants in lifting young women UP to a greater good.
This young blogger most certainly deserves a more mature response from an adult who is in a leadership role!
"... try finding something more productive to do with your time." This was your final line to this young woman?????????
My dear woman, you know NOTHING about this young lady. And if you did, you would want your own young girls to be able to emulate her courage, her conviction, her intelligence, her thirst for knowledge - and the care and compassion she has shown to young people around the world!
Please take some time to consider what I have written. And please take some time to re-think your responsibilities as a leader. The young people you influence and lead deserve that!